Skip to main content

Thoughts on the 2017 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot


Another year, another Hall of Fame class decided, and as always, there are all sorts of eyebrow raising shenanigans going on with it. Of course, this is all my point of view, the way everyone else has an opinion and viewpoint whenever these results are revealed in January. 

First, let me say congrats to Jeff Bagwell, Tim Raines, and Ivan Rodriguez. All of them are tremendous players, none carries any doubt of their legitimacy for the Hall of Fame. Just tremendous ball players who deserve the day they have coming to them in Cooperstown in July. I'm actually super stoked for Raines, who was such a complete player.

But of course, this year's results have all sorts of head scratchers, most notably, surrounding the always-popular-steroid discussion. I'll air my grievances as such: 

- We need to come to a consensus on the feeling of PED use/suspicion. Jeff Bagwell, who had "whispers" around him using PEDs, similar to that of Mike Piazza, got in, yet, Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens remain on this pseudo-punishment-waiting-list? I'm not sure the message being sent here. 

- And as always, my belief is that it isn't a Hall of Fame if Bonds ain't in it. I know that's not popular among fans, but Barry Bonds is the greatest player of my lifetime. The dude was insane. 

- Speaking of PED's, how in the world of worlds (of all of the worlds), does Manny Ramirez muster  a vote of 23.8%? WHAT?! Ramirez was busted twice - TWICE - for PED use, and we're talking AFTER it was frowned upon to be juicing. So baffling. 

- Ditto the same type of sentiment for those who punched tabs for Jason Varitek and Edgar Renteria. But, some of these writers will tell you about the integrity of their vote and how they take their selection seriously. 

If my logic adds up, it doesn't matter if you have whispers of PED usage, or that you in fact failed multiple PED tests, you just can't be well...I have no idea. Apparently you just can't be Barry Bonds or Roger Clemens. And if you are, that just sucks for you. 

- On a brighter note, it seems Trevor Hoffman will get his call next year. As evident from this blog, I'm partial to my relief brethrens, and Hoffman deserves it. It's a shame that Lee Smith couldn't get the same amount of support to get in.

As you can imagine, I can't wait for Mariano Rivera to go in. I'll have to make the trip to Cooperstown for that. And yes, I also can't wait to see the writers (now that ballots are available to the public) who decided he wasn't worthy of their selection. You know it will happen. Because Babe Ruth didn't get...yada yada yada. 

- The whole "DHs don't deserve to be in the Hall of Fame" narrative is so tired. The hypocrisy is so strong when guys get in the Hall of Fame based on their defensive ability, yet, somehow, there is this backlash over one of the best right handed hitters not getting in because he filled a legal position created by baseball. Add another "unwritten rule of baseball" that is ridiculous. 

- I hope Moose gets in someday. He is one of my favorite pitchers of all-time. Really, really enjoyed Mussina on the bump. 

- Speaking of favorites, Gary Sheffield is a tremendously underrated player. Check the numbers. And take a look at his versatility as a player.

- Vlad Guerrero was robbed. He's first ballot material. I'll leave it at that. 

- And finally, I absolutely love how passionate baseball fans are when it comes to the Hall of Fame. It carries so much honor and prestige, especially in comparison to the other sports. Despite all of the opinions, arguments, emotions, and cynicism that comes with the election process, people care, and for the game of baseball, that's very, very cool. 

Looking forward to future Hall of Fame debates to come. 

Recently Read Posts

Goodbye Melo

I've wanted this for the Knicks, and today I got it.

Carmelo Anthony is no longer a New York Knick heading into the 17-18 NBA Season.

No, I don't dislike Melo. In fact, if you go through previous posts you'll know, I find Melo to be a very, very good player. However, I just thought it was time for the Knicks to move past this era, and truly - like, really - rebuild.

Most importantly, build around Kristaps Porzingis.

But, again, for me, I've always - ALWAYS - believed that Carmelo Anthony needed to be the #2 (or #3) guy on a team. Watching him night in and night out as a Knick, he just never seemed to be the type of guy who lifts those around him. Again, he's a tremendous player but the track record is there. I don't buy into the "he's never had much around him" argument.

Have you seen the Knicks roster in comparison to the rest of the Eastern Conference the last few years?

Sunday Sundown Rundown - 9/24/17

3 Up
1. Efforts for Maria - Maria has been horrific for many of the Caribbean islands. Barbuda continues to get pummeled, and of course (and most notably), we've seen the images of devastation in Puerto Rico. But much kudos to people like Tim Duncan, Jorge Posada, Yadier Molina, Jenifer Lopez, and so many more who are leading the aid for some of these areas. 
2. LeBron James - Yo, LeBron James went from being one of my favorite athletes to one of my favorite celebrities in responding the President Trump's outlandish speech. Love the "u bum" part too. But seriously, everything about it was great, especially so because he's a public figure. 
3. Athletes and Politics - It was interesting to see the two mix heavily this weekend after our President decided to take the country to these intersection of life. Regardless, kudos to so many athletes (NFL, NBA, WNBA, MLS, MLB, and more) who handled the situation correctly, and even furthered the movement. 
3 Down
1. Mexico Ci…

Dome Pondering - 2012 Year in Review

Mic check. One, two, three. Mic check. Okay, so we're on, and hey, we're still alive! Stupid Mayans. Welcome to the DP's signature post of the year, the Year in Review. Each year, as we did last (Dome Pondering Year in Review - 2011), we take a look back at the calendar year and prepare for the next one ahead. With a packed and eventful 2012, there is much to delve into and plenty to prepare for in 2013. 
Before we do, I'd like to simply thank all of the DP devotees out there for your continued support and interest in this little blog called Dome Pondering. While it seems I've come to say the same thing every time at this part of the year, it bears repeating that this site full of my thoughts and words has grown tremendously over the last three years because of you. It seems the older I become and the less time I have, the more I am able to punch the keys. I don't get it either, and I'm not even going to try to figure it out. Nonetheless, thank you once ag…

Sunday Sundown Rundown - 9/17/17

3 Up
1. JJ Wyatt - Not only has the man raised over $37M for Hurricane Harvey relief, but unlike many of the various charities we have become accustomed to, Wyatt is very transparent in how he will spend the money, and what he plans to do. Still in such awe of this. 
2. Tim Duncan - In the same spectrum as Wyatt is one of my favorite athletes, Tim Duncan. A native from the US Virgin Islands, Tim Duncan has been instrumental in Hurricane Irma relief by donating 20,000 pounds of food to the area. Such awesome stories in the midst of all these Natural disasters. The power of the human spirit is so great. 
3. Cleveland Indians - 22 Baseball games in a row. The Indians record winning-streak came to an end  this week, but it is damn impressive. Are they NOT the choice to make it back to the World Series from the American League? 
3 Down
1. London Attacks - SMH on these terrorists attacks. My heart goes out to those affected by more senselessness in the world. 
2. White House on Jemele Hill -…