Skip to main content

Stoudemire's Knicks Legacy: Disappointing, Unfulfilled, & Expected...But Much Respect


Five years ago, Amar'e Stoudemire signed a huge 5 year, $100M contract, allowing Knicks fans to exhale a little bit in their hunger to walk away with anything during the prized free agent class of 2010. You know, the year this sorry organization that I gave my heart too, pretty much forfeited two years of basketball prior to that summer in another misguided attempt to rebuild.

As I stated on this very blog the day we signed Stoudemire, I wasn't overly thrilled with the signing, due to the obvious warning signs. In fact here is what I stated: 

"And although he is not the acquisition every Knick fan wants, and although I originally did not warm to the idea of acquiring Stoudemire when it was first rumored, today I am excited – very excited. 
Albeit, I will admit, I am worried about his knee. I am worried about his interior defense and rebound production. And yes, I will definitely miss the one shining light in a dark era that was David Lee. However, the one sole reason I have warmed to Stoudemire as a Knick is simple – he wants to be on the big stage. He wants to be here. He wants a piece of this great city of New York." ("The Knicks Are Back")

On the day of his official introduction, Stoudemire stood in front of the "World's Most Famous Arena" and proclaimed "The Knicks are back!" I loved it. I really did. It meant so much to me as a Knick fan to hear a superstar come here, embrace the challenge of playing here, and really - genuinely - wanting to take this franchise to the promise land, a place it hasn't seen for forty-plus years and counting now. 

Of course, we know how the story went. And to be honest, even without hindsight, we knew how the story would go. Stoudemire gave us a MVP-like season, then essentially broke down. And did so badly. New Yorkers watched the crumbling of Stoudemire before our eyes. 

And of course there were the moments of the idiotic pre-game dunk before a playoff game, the punching of the fire extinguisher, and the plenty of aggravating times we saw him dressed in very spiffy outfits, rather than donning the orange and blue on game nights. 

On the other end of that is the class in which Stoudemire represented the Knicks. Never complaining about coming off the bench, and never truly having any surrounding controversy that would embarrass the organization. 

In some ways, Stoudemire, in his brief 7 months as the face of the New York Knicks, pre Carmelo Anthony, of course, was a indeed a credible face of the franchise.

Now that this journey has ended and he is on his way to Dallas to play for the Mavericks, the Stoudemire reflection has begun by this city and all Knicks fans. Some may call it disappointing, others unfulfilled, and a few, merely expected (injuries an all). I can't disagree with any of the those statements. However, if there is one thing I'll add to the growing list of descriptions is respect. Stoudemire was and still is, no offense to the Melo supporters, the first Knicks in a very long time to take the challenge of New York and the Knicks organization when no one would.

Which is ironic, five years later, this organization is in the very same position. Unbelievable...

Regardless, Thank you Amar'e Stoudemire. You tried. Much respect. Go get a ring elsewhere (like everyone else does). I'll be rooting for you. 

Recently Read Posts

Sunday Sundown Rundown - 11/12/17

3 Up
1. Aly Raisman - Following the bravery of Mckayla Maroney and others in the #MeToo campaign, Raisman has stepped forward as the charges pile up for sexual abuse by former USA Gymnastics doctor, Larry Nassar. By the way, shame on USA Gymnastics for continuing to allow this culture. I shudder to think what else lies in the world of Gymnastics. 
2. New York Times - In a world where journalism - real journalism - is becoming harder and harder to find, The Times continues to break stories left and right, and did so again this week with the Louis CK piece. I think we all are tired of journalism wrapped in identity politics, and yes, even "fake news". 
3. Kristaps Porzingis - Obviously, you all know how much I love the Unicorn. But seriously, how enjoyable is he to watch? And barring injury, he can only get better. Melo, who? 
3 Down
1. Sean Hannity - Seriously, I don't even know how this guy sleeps at night. And really, I'm not even sure what kind of person follows thi…

Pondering Picture #82

I snapped this photo in midtown Manhattan following a meeting with believe it or not, various professors from my alma mater of Cazenovia College. It was tremendous catching up with them all, especially considering it's been ten-plus years since I've seen them. 
Sometimes, honestly, it's almost like I forget I spent four years in upstate New York. And when I am reminded of it, often I am amazed in how a such a small town helped prepare me to tackle the big city, New York City - my home. 
Life is crazy.

Dome Pondering Movie Review: The Big Sick (2017)

What is it about?

The true story of Pakistani-born, Kumail Nanjiani who falls in love with Emily. After she becomes ill with a mysterious illness, Kumail must come to grips with various truths and culture clashes he's been avoiding. 
Who is in it? 
Kumail Nunjiani - Kumail
Emily - Zoe Kazan
Holly Hunter - Beth
Ray Romano - Terry

Dome Pondering Movie Review: Facing The Giants (2006)

What’s it about?
A High School Football coach and his football team overcomes many fears personally and professionally by rededicating themselves to faith.
Who is in it?
Alex Kendrick – Grant Taylor
Shannen Fields – Brooke Taylor
Jason Mcleod – Brock Kelley