Skip to main content

March Sadness


This post has been coming for awhile, and it now seems like the best time to do so...

So, here goes...

Division I Basketball is getting more and more difficult for me to watch and support. 

Just like I once laid out regarding my ethical feelings towards the NFL (and really, football, overall), thus is the same credence and feelings I have developing for Division I Basketball - mainly the NCAA's approach to it. Now of course, my feelings aren't something new as many share my thoughts and opinions on this - the NCAA is corrupt and college basketball is a sham. But for me, it goes even deeper - certain programs, coaches, and communities enable this exploitation of young men. And yes, many shy away from that word, but that's exactly what college basketball has become, an exploitation of services.

If you know me and you read this blog, you'll know that the irony in all of this is that I am a member of the NCAA. However, I work at a Division III school, and while many often scoff at those athletes and programs, those are the ones who often get the model correct - student athlete. Developing students first. 

Student's first. People first. 

But here is the thing, how does anyone, with a clear understanding of how the NCAA operates, vouch for a system that generates billions of dollars for executives, television networks, coaches, and programs, when these players don't receive a dime or at the least fair compensation in the process?

But, they get a free education!

False. Not all do. And that for me, a student affairs practitioner at heart, compounds the problem. Funds are used for students who will never receive a degree from an institution, taking away opportunities for even more willing and able students to enroll in higher education, and even more so, underrepresented students with already limited access. For what? Basketball? A crooked system? 

As for coaches, it's amazing how these beings have become almost "god-like" in specific regions and communities in which they work. Some, working at state institutions, are on the record books as some of the highest paid employees of said state. That's just crazy to me! Absolutely crazy!  

But what really bothers me is the way some of these coaches rack up violations without any regard for the punishment, and often, it's the schools and student-athletes who feel repercussions. The way they take off for the next school, or break contracts without any fear. 

And sometimes, the way these communities defend these coaches with violations and shady shenanigans happening under their helm. 

The question I always raise is this - is the priority for DI coaches to develop further students and individuals, or to simply win basketball games for the University? Often, what feels like a hand-in-hand journey, has become the latter. 

Unfortunately, the NCAA tells us it stands for one, and does the other.

Thus, what we get is creating this "madness" built around the gambling and again - exploitation - of free labor of young men playing basketball. And again, the billions and billions of dollars generated around a kids who are shackled by policies that prevent them from pure and honest revenue generation such as selling an autograph or being paid for an appearance in town. 

Or as we've seen from O'Bannon v. NCAA - the countless times likenesses and images are used without a student's consent? 

Want more proof of "amateurism"? How many "amateur" sports have press and media detail following a contest? 

The way these kids are never defended or protected by the NCAA and it's subjective and nonsensical rules is beyond absurd. The way traditionally-aged college students (17-21 years old) have to communicate after losses and wins to an educated and vulture-like press is an example of this mess and shame that is the NCAA Tournament.

Not to mention, have you read internet boards on some of these fan sites? Or, sports radio in some of these college towns? Or how about Twitter...ah yes, good ol' positive Twitter!! That was sarcasm by the way...there is nothing amateur in this process. 

I do believe in college spirit and what higher education institutions do for a community and area. And I do believe that there is a place and a stage for the best college student-athletes in the nation to shine on. I do also believe there is an opportunity for student-athletes to have an experience they will one have a handful of times at most in their lives. 

But it can't be like this. 

What would I do to fix it? How about for starters, no advertising allowed for these NCAA events? What if the NCAA adopted the same rules it holds it's student-athletes to, and subjugate themselves to limited access and opportunities to not tarnish "amateurism". What if the NCAA went sponsor-less for the entire event. No commercials. No billboards. No selling of outside commercial America on the backs on these men? You know, the same exact way these kids aren't allowed to monetize their experience. 

It's not perfect, but it's a start. 

But the reality is this, college basketball has an interesting crossroads coming up soon with the NBA soon adopting a European style model of Academies and Camps. Adam Silver and the always progressive NBA are headed towards drafting straight out of high school once again with the opportunity to have players have direct ties to a NBA Franchise and their G-League team. 

The best talent in America will soon be headed straight to the NBA once again. And to be honest, as a fan of the game, this might be the better option to help keep the game moving forward. 

Again, I apologize if this sounds like me on my soap box - but it is me being thoroughly honest. I'm torn watching these games. I want to support the student-athlete, you know, the pure wholistic, unbiased, and untainted vision it was meant to be. But there is that part of me that absolutely despises how these three weeks happen, and how the sweat and hard work - and often, lifestyle struggles - of some of these students are used and abused. Many who eventually leave school without a degree.

Those coaches are the worst in my eyes. The true criminals in this entire system. 

Again, it's getting more difficult to watch Division I basketball. I'm just curious how long before others come around to realizing it for what it is. Unlike football, which I wouldn't cry if it went away, I want change for college basketball. And as always, it should be student-first. 

Recently Read Posts

Sunday Sundown Rundown - 9/23/18

3 Up

1. Eluide Kipchoge - I'm always impressed with any running feat. But come on! This dude just broke the World record for not just any running feat - for a freakin marathon! He finished the Berlin Marathon in 2 hours 1 Minute and 39 seconds!! Kipchoge ran his first 10 kilometers in 29:21! That's just insane. So insane.

2. John Legend - Props this dude for completing the EGOT, and of course, becoming the first black person to do so. That is some big time, historical, accomplishment-stuff.

3. Tiger Woods - Do I care about golf? Not really. Not even when Woods was in his prime. Yet, who doesn't love a great comeback sports story? I'm still not OK with how he treated his ex-wife, but I'm always up for a redemption story. I do like seeing people rebound.

3 Down

1. Florence Death Toll - With the numbers rising as the days go by, it's a shame to see the aftermath of such a storm in the Carolinas. Here is to hoping we can get help to the region sufficiently.

2. Kavan…

The Pondering 10 – All-Time Animated Cartoons

Every individual enjoyed cartoons as a child. While today’s youth may not have many options, or even care for cartoons, for generations in the past, cartoons provided many hours of laughter, memories, and overall entertainment. In the following Pondering 10 list, yours truly will name my all-time favorite cartoons. This list is by far the hardest list compiled hear on the DP due to the enormous amount of cartoons that were great, as well as putting together a profound and honest list based on quality and interest. In doing so, I have left out such cartoons such as Family Guy and King of The Hill, as these are more connected to the present time rather than childhood memories. Also, please keep in mind, the following cartoons have must be noted as an honorable mention: Duck Tales, Goof Troop, The Jetsons, Thundercats, Darkwing Duck, Tale Spin, Gargoyles, Batman, Pinky and the Brain, Speed Racer, Doug, Garfield, Bobby’s World, Sonic The Hedgehog, Ghostbusters, Tailspin, Captain Planet, …

True Tales From Parks and Recreation - Public Bait and Switch?

Note: I work for a park slowly in continuing development in Manhattan that is five miles along the waterfront of the Hudson River. As a Public Programs Coordinator, yours truly handles anything public related in regards to permitting (athletic facilities, film shoots, photo shoots, weddings, and other small gatherings), and of course, dealing with any questions or inquiries from the public. The following series will present stories, e-mails, phone calls, conversations, interactions, and sights I've seen from the people of New York City in regards to a public park. And yes, these are all real! And are all true!
Welcome to another little snippet of Parks and Recreation.

Pondering with Plumtree - "That Was Awesome" - Thoughts, Lessons, and Ponderings From TNA's NYC Tapings

Pondering with Plumtree is a column on the popular blog, TNAsylum, that is written by yours truly. The blog is focused towards being a fan site for TNA Wrestling fans where they can get news, rumors, opinions, and any and everything else, TNA Wrestling. Known as "The Haven for TNA Wrestling Fans", I'm hoping to bring some of my thoughts to an already impressive roster of columnist for as long as the site will have me. You can read the latest column here, or in the text below.