Skip to main content

Thoughts on the 2016 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot


The 2016 MLB Hall of Fame induction ceremony this year will be highly anticipated by every baseball fan who grew up in the 90's. The selection of Ken Griffey Jr. and Mike Piazza feels well deserved, nostalgic, and honestly, an opportunity for the game of baseball to romanticize about some of the greatest - not just Hall of Famers, but GREATEST - players to have ever put on a baseball uniform. 

Sometimes I wished the induction ceremonies were part of the All-Star festivities and not just a random week in the summer. I want a huge spectacle out of this! But whatevs.

Regardless, as I've stated in the past, the shunning of Piazza was rather ridiculous, especially when t was based on speculation, or anticipated speculation, right Bill Madden? But I still respect Madden for disclosing and explaining his vote. That's all one can ask for.  

As for Griffey, the dude was so boss. From the swing, the athleticism, the power, the smile, the backwards hat, the sneakers, the whole entire package and swag was transcending in a sport where all of it is not easy to do. That sort of marketing stuff only comes easy to basketball players. And oh yeah, he did it in Seattle!

Again, major congrats to Junior and Piazza. Well deserved. 

Here are some other quick tidbits from the Hall of Fame announcement: 

Griffey's Swing

Call me crazy, but shouldn't Griffey's swing also be inducted into the Hall of Fame? Quite frankly, it may just make the DP Page of Fame this summer, and don't be surprised if it does. I love that swing. Still do. No one had a sweeter swing than Griff. Ever. Really, ever. No one.



99.3% 

The last few years I've complained about the always anticipated but never shocking situation of "who didn't vote for (fill in the blank). I can do that with Griffey here, as three knuckleheads apparently looked at Griffey's career and just didn't think it was worthy of Cooperstown enshrinement. Maybe they compared him to his videogame counterpart where he ALWAYS went yard on the N64. That's a tough comparison, and I can see that reasoning a little bit. 

Seriously though, 99.3% is the highest vote ever. Griffey deserves it. And yes, I do see Rivera and Jeter both smashing that record in a few years. But then again, there is always that guy, right? 

All you have to do is see that Jason Kendall, Garrett Anderson, and Mike Sweeney received votes. Ugh.

Maybe Next Year? 

Jeff Bagwell votes became more of a thing in 2016 as he jumped from receiving 55.7% to 71.6%. This bodes rough for Bagwell in being patient, but it seems like 2017 may be his year. 

Speaking of 2017, I'm sure Tim Raines squeaks in on his final year of eligibility on the ballot. Rock has waited long enough. 

I wouldn't also be surprised if Trevor Hoffman somehow joins them as well. 

Moose Still Average

Mike Mussina is one of my favorite pitchers of all-time. Looking at his numbers, it's borderline criminal how overshadowed he's been in this process. 

Underrated Sheff

Speaking of being overlooked, am I the only one who believes Gary Sheffield is a certified and legit Hall of Fame contender? Not saying he's first ballot, or even a sure thing, but the guy has a legit argument when you consider his numbers (against others), the various positions he has played, and the amount of big moments he has produced in. 

Plus the stance with the super bat waggle was fantastic. 

Are We All Clear On When to Vote?

Barry has to eventually get in, right? This is all pretty much punishing him by making him wait, no? Seriously, it has to be, yeah? Come on guys, we are eventually electing Barry Bonds, right? 

Let's just make sure we do it together. Wait, we are still doing that? That is still the plan, correct?

Sammy, Who? 

Sammy Sosa received just 7% and may see his fate come to an end on the ballot in 2016. Just do me a favor and glance at Sosa's lines. I can't even wrap my mind around some of those numbers. 

[sidenote: Baseball Reference is practically my mental home away from reality. I find myself looking at the most random statistics on there whenever my mind drifts. Hmmm, what did Clay Bellinger hit in 2000? That sort of thing. Not healthy at all.]

Sadly, a part of me believes future generations to come will be just as confused as I am by Sosa's stat lines and what his legacy really is - more baffling is that I actually saw him play and haven't the faintest clue. Good luck future baseball fans! 

Finally, in what has become tradition here at the DP, and since I thoroughly believe every voter should disclose their votes, I will give you the official DP Hall of Fame ballot if I had one: 

  • Ken Griffey Jr. 
  • Mike Piazza 
  • Tim Raines
  • Jeff Bagwell
  • Gary Sheffield
  • Mike Mussina
  • Jeff Kent
  • Edgar Martinez
  • Trevor Hoffman
  • Curt Schilling

And...

*Barry Bonds

Because we're all done punishing Bonds and Clemens and voting for real on them next year, right guys? Or is it the year afterwards? Or shoot, did I miss the memo on them for this year? Crap. 

Recently Read Posts

Dome Pondering Export - "TNA's Biggest Problem Is..."

After ten years of importing materials, words, pictures, and videos from other sites her for your viewing and for archiving, I never thought I'd get to the point where I'd be EXPORTING material out to other sites. Yes, the DP continues to grow, and yours truly had the kind opportunity to contribute a guest column to an awesome Pro Wrestling blog with a very large audience. The piece has since been very well received, and I hope to have the opportunity to do so in the future, and maybe even other sites and avenues as well. 
You can read the column here on the TNAsylum website (special thanks to them as well for posting), or the entire text below:

Sunday Sundown Rundown - 10/22/17

3 Up

1. #MeToo - Kudos and so much props to all of the women who shared their stories of being abused. I personally read the stories of former students I am connected with on social media, and the stories abound are a wake up call to all of us men. We need to be better.

2. Los Angeles Dodgers - Just one loss all postseason, and the best team in baseball all year long now find themselves on the big stage in the World Series. They'll have their workout cutout against a tough Astros team.

3. AJ Styles - One of my favorite pro wrestlers of all-time performed in Chile, received a phone call to cover a match not happening, then appeared at WWE TLC against Finn Balor in a memorable night. The life of pro wrestlers are so, so, so rough. Kudos to Styles on delivering - like he always does.

3 Down

1. Somalia Attack - First, the story of the Somalia bombing is horrific. The thought that it wasn't covered as much as other terrorist attacks says so much about the Western world. Second, sham…

Thoughts After the 2017 ALCS Loss

Well, it finally came to an end, and yes, I am disappointed. I know I said "whatever happens in the ALCS" in my previous post following the ALDS clincher over the Indians, but this one still hurts. Yes, the Yankees were in an unfamiliar role as underdog being in their "rebuilding" year and that's seems to be the medicine everyone is taking for this pain, but you know what? ALCS appearances don't come around too often - even if you're the New York Yankees - and going this far shouldn't ever - EVER - be taken for granted.

I wanted this series. I wanted the World Series. I wanted the Dodgers in the Fall Classic.

But instead, Houston, the better, more deserving team in the series, gets the nod for the American League.

Despite all of the emotions and adrenaline settling now that the 2017 season is over, I am in fact excited for April. There are a lot of pieces in play, plenty of money off the books (officially saying goodbye to A-Rod), and of course, th…

Sunday Sundown Rundown - 10/15/17

3 Up
1. Hollywood Victims - Much props to the many men and women who have taken the step in telling their story about sexual assault and being the victim of displays of power for sexual gain within Hollywood. It's tough, especially in such an unforgiving business like show business, but it takes guts to tell the truth - much respect to you all who did so.
2. Joe Girardi - Have you ever seen a more brutally honest manager or head coach during a playoff stretch? Girardi has been letting his soul bare on mistakes, feelings, lineups, results, decisions, his family, his time in New York, and anything and everything else. I have a feeling Girardi is walking away, after this season, and if he is, I'm glad he's doing it by just being him. 
3. Eminem - I've seen some new school fans insult Eminem and downplaying his ability. I'm still a fan. After all, no one - NO ONE - captures anger in their music like Em. No one. Still so captivating. And yes, his freestyle of President …