Skip to main content

Pondering with Plumtree - GFW Aside, Real Hope Still Within TNA

Pondering with Plumtree is a column on the popular blog, TNAsylum, that is written by yours truly. The blog is focused towards being a fan site for TNA Wrestling fans where they can get news, rumors, opinions, and any and everything else, TNA Wrestling. Known as "The Haven for TNA Wrestling Fans", I'm hoping to bring some of my thoughts to an already impressive roster of columnist for as long as the site will have me. You can read the latest column here, or in the text below.


Call me crazy, but I am not at all overwhelmingly excited by the recent TNA-GFW developments. Call me a "hater", a "smark", or whatever the latest term to describe someone who gives a disagreeing opinion, but the recent developments are not exciting to me, just merely intriguing. 

I'll admit, I was shocked to see Jeff Jarrett return a couple of weeks ago to TNA by appearing on Impact. The moment made for great television and a great TNA wrestling moment.

Despite the memorable segment, the whole issue of GFW just doesn't connect with me as of yet. Quite frankly, what is GFW? Don't get me wrong, I'm all for TNA having solid and beneficial partnerships with other companies, something it rarely has experienced, but I struggle to become excited about GFW until it actually is a tangible, existing product that this consumer can experience. It's even harder to do so when the roster and "feel" thus far feels like a throwback to the old TNA, or dare I say, Jarrett's way of "doing it his way (or right) this time." 

Again, I could be wrong, but I have nothing to go off of until I see a television show or some actual content or you know, WRESTLING!

The talks of invasions, and crossover story lines, and other types of hopes, dreams, and wishes from wrestling fans are fine. All just part of the great essence that makes wrestling fandom - dreamlike scenarios. But for me, it really feels like (possibly signifies?) some TNA fans grasping for more. For something ultimately significant to get beyond the string of behind-the-scenes news, whether they are true or not. 

TNA fandom has been tough. Anyone or any website that attempts to portray differently is not being truthful. As enjoyable as the television show has been (not counting this past week, which I found hard to really get into), there is always the constant rumor mill and shakeups that overshadow the product. Reality is: TNA Negative Discussion > TNA Wrestling Product. That may just be a sign of our times as fans. So sad. 

Nonetheless, for me, the search is deeper than hopes of invasions, or overcoming negative news. My connection to TNA Wrestling has waned over the years due to one thing - inconsistency. It's TNA Wrestling's biggest fault. 

As a fan since day one, I now look at the old guard, the "TNA originals", and wonder countless "what ifs". A group who truly built TNA, but were never - EVER - given an opportunity to run with the ball. Not just hold the World Title, but reeeeeally run with the ball as the faces of the company. 

And now there is more negative news with more losses of talent, some thought to be the second crop of TNA branded stars. Guys such as Magnus. 

There is also the obvious "lessening" of the company from a touring, full fledged promotion that I once hoped would make its way to New York City all the time, to now having to settle for it existing as a television brand, and only for those purposes. 

As a TNA loyal fan since night one, I always come back to what I feel are TNA's most significant moments towards my fandom: 1) Kurt Angle's headbutt heard around the world to Samoa Joe, which proved there was something really special going on in TNA Wrestling at the time, and 2) When Hulk Hogan, standing alongside Eric Bischoff, uttered the words "We're changing it, whether you like or not" inside a four sided ring to the chants of "We want six sides" from the Impact Zone on the January 19th, 2010 edition of Impact. 

My light on that crazy fandom for TNA Wrestling flickered out then. The company became just another, like the others. That may sound extreme, but it wasn't by choice. I still support and really enjoy the product. I just never had that overwhelming super-fandom since then.

I'm not sure what the TNA-GFW situation will bring and present. It may very well be something that is tremendous, and I hope it is. However, my hope going forward for TNA, as a company, as a chance to find itself as unique brand, and even to thwart the negative news that plagues it, is not wrapped up in invasions, partnerships, talent-exchanges, cross-promotion shows, Jeff Jarrett himself, reverting back to the "old TNA", or even bringing back more wrestlers from it's past. 

In an odd circle of re-birth, TNA has, once again, a handful of names and talent on their roster who have the opportunity to make this their chance to re-build TNA. EC3. Bram. The Wolves. Spud. Jesse. Robbie. And many more who probably will be added in the coming weeks and months.

The current state of TNA and he hope in a GFW involvement seems like another big swing for the fences attempt with band-aid like solutions to real issues. The current roster of core prospects can be viewed as the opportunity for the up and coming stars on this roster to rebuild the company in a new TNA-branded way, and yes, actually carry the ball in doing so. 

Call me crazy (again), but TNA might have their second wave of core talent on their hands, all with blank canvases, all with the opportunity to be developed into TNA-branded stars.

If you wanted something to hold on to, something to grasp onto to, something more as a fan, this may just be it.

This may just be the kind of "re-start" TNA always needed. 


Random Rhetoric:

How great was the moment of EC3 breaking out of the "grapevined" version of Angle's ankle lock from last week? 

And wasn't that match a great story told? 

Anyone else find Tyrus to be a great fit to EC3's character? 

And if you were like me in groaning upon his initial appearance - ugh, great, it's Brodus Clay - then hasn't he considerably surprised you? And we sort of owe the big fella an apology, don't we? 

Hasn't the BroMans break up been fun to watch? 

Shouldn't Jesse's use of the chair for his Adonis Lock become part of his whole character? 

Because quite frankly, how awesome was that?!

Wouldn't you like to see Robbie E continue to evolve and become more serious, bro? 

Yeah, sorry, I guess I do too. 

How amazing is Bram? And doesn't he have a fitting theme song as well as a terrific nickname in the "Chesterfield Plague"?

Can we get more Bobby Lashley? Dude's a beast.

And finally...

Can't an argument be made that EC3 is TNA's best developed character - EVER? 

Recently Read Posts

Sante Fe Thoughts, and More Tired Thoughts on School Shootings

It was too similar to Columbine for me. I still remember as a 13 year old staying home from school sick, then suddenly finding my being sobering up on all illnesses watching in horror that unfolded in Colorado. 
Yesterday, I was home from work, and thus did the same thing. Glued to the couch. Flipping between channels. Refreshing my Twitter feed. Trying to find out details in horror. Once again shocked, angered, frustrated, and saddened. 
We now live in an America where 22 school shootings have occurred in 2018 - a calendar year still young in it's existence. Seriously, let that sink in. And if it take a moment to wrap your head around it, that's because its absurd, and it's also so engrained in our culture, in our everyday realm of societal possibility. School shootings? Wow - unbelievable.

Sunday Sundown Rundown - 5/20/18

3 Up
1. JJ Watt - Watt is just a stand-up guy. No other way to say it. An athlete that embraces the city he plays in, in times of good, and when he is needed. Paying for the funerals of all of the victims in the latest school shooting is just another example of the kind of dude Watt really is. So much props. 
2. Sante Fe Admins - So many times in these shootings, the efforts and bravery of the many who help to keep students safe, calm, and diffuse the situation often goes without praise and notice. Once again, much love and praise to those who did so once again. And yes, to those who lost their lives doing so as well. 
3. Las Vegas Golden Knights - In their inaugural season, the Golden Knights are in the Stanley Cup Finals, and quite frankly, could possibly win the whole damn thing. It's so impressive, and speaks to the parity of the NHL. But really, if you're a fan of a team currently in a drought (say, like my New York Knicks?), this run is absolutely remarkable. 
3 Down
1. S…

The Pondering 10 - Issues/Annoyances with College Basketball Product

Following the month of March and all of the madness that comes with it during the NCAA Tournament, the product that is college basketball has been an issue. It is no secret to most, and to the very denial of die hard college basketball fans, the overall quality has taken a step back. Recently, College basketball ambassador and analyst, Jay Bilas, gave his honest opinion on the state of college basketball, and believes it has been poor the last three seasons. As a fan of the overall sport, I do watch college basketball, but am more invested and interested in the NBA. After receiving much backlash on twitter and here at the DP, I've decided to turn my reasoning for not being interested in the college product into the latest Pondering 10 list.

The Pondering 10 - Favorite MLB Uniforms

Unlike most sports, baseball uniforms carry a lot of tradition and history. It's rare that you see baseball teams deviate away from the history of a club, and if they do, it's usually an ownership change. For the most part, in baseball, the uniforms are sacred. Because of that, Major League Baseball has many teams with uniforms that are very, very significant, and also, very stylish. As we did for the NFL (Pondering 10 - Favorite NFL Uniforms), the following Pondering 10 will take a look at my favorite MLB uniforms.